Don’t Gift the Business

How to sell between generations

June 6, 2022
Shutterstock1877890609

There are many pitfalls in transitioning ownership of a small business to the next generation. I know. I’ve seen many owners over the past 30 years deal with just that. Probably the biggest misconception is that the business should be gifted. It shouldn’t. It should be sold. Here’s why.

We want to successfully transition to the next generation while keeping the family intact.

Parents are usually eternally optimistic and see a world where all three of the siblings are so devoted to the business as to deserve to share equally. While each situation is unique, I often see it differently.

Here’s one scenario.

A son toiled in the business for 20 years, splitting the monthly profits with the parents, while dad, who started the business with junior, pursued other interests. At some point, the son approached the parents about transitioning the business. Their response was, “What about your sisters?”

Oh, yes, the sisters. One married the local doctor and the other married the town lawyer and both blossomed into town socialites. Neither gave the business much thought beyond working in the bindery during high school.

The upshot of the horrid story was that the parents cut the sisters in for 10% each, so junior now toiled away running the business and got to keep only 40% of the profits, with the parents getting the other 40%.

In this case, the parents violated the first principle of fairness. They mistook equality as fairness. It’s not. Fairness means being fair with the opportunity, not dividing the business proportionally.

The sisters had an opportunity to work in the business but chose a different path. Only the son stayed and did his job, for which he was paid. Not only that but he went above and beyond with “sweat equity.” He attended the local community college in his spare time and took accounting classes, business law and other basic courses in business. He didn’t get a degree mind you; he didn’t need to. The knowledge is what counted.

Imagine the scenarios had the business been split three ways with the two sisters as absentee owners and the brother as operator. How much should the brother be paid? Should the sisters get a salary? What about dividends?

When the business is sold to the next generation, that’s avoided. The proceeds are added to the parents' estate to do with what they will. They may pass it along equally among all siblings or spend it. Their choice.

As for the siblings, favorites were not played. Junior wasn’t given the business. He bought it. If necessary, all three could have bid against each other for the right to the business, or two of them, or all of them could have put together a proposal.

Most importantly, the process is fair.

If the business isn’t worth what the parents need for retirement, then it’s up to the parents to make it worth more. After all, we run the business until we don’t.

“Sweat equity,” on the other hand, is the collateral built up by the son to allow the parents to “loan” money to the son to buy the business. His attending community college is an example.

The parents build up the fair market value to what they wish, then the son buys the business in exchange for a promissory note to pay the parents the value of the business over time.

If the business is worth $700,000 (yes, I do business valuations), then the son puts down enough of his and his spouse’s cash as to gain their attention. After all, you don’t want them walking away when times get tough. In this case, let’s say it’s $35,000.

That’s not a magic payment formula, rather the down payment must be reasonable as to what they can afford. But it must be enough that junior must gain his spouse’s agreement as well.

Then the parents finance the remaining $665,000, which amounts to monthly payments of $4,030 at 4% interest for 20 years paid out of the business. The length of the term and interest rate could be negotiated and would vary depending on the age of the parents and the going rate of interest.

Here’s the point. Prior to closing, the parents run the business and are responsible for all debts and decisions. Once the transaction is done, the son or daughter owns the business and is responsible for all debts and decisions.

The parents then are only creditors who have as much influence on operations as any other creditor.

Remember, you run the business until you don’t. Should you want more for the business than it’s worth, make it worth more. Then sell it to the next generation. But don’t gift the business. Especially don’t leave it to siblings who won’t be working in it. That’s guaranteed to assure they won’t spend time together over the holidays.

= = = = =

Tom Crouser helps printers prosper through consulting and coaching. Message him at [email protected] or call his cell (304) 541-3714. There’s no cost or obligation.